Blue crab meat gently tossed with Old Bay Seasoning and just a few other ingredients pan fried or baked in a muffin tin the way my grandma made them in Maryland.
JUMP TO RECIPEOh, I am a lucky, lucky girl. Not only did I have the privilege of being raised in the Deep South where I learned all about Southern cooking, but my mom and her family are from Maryland. So I got all the best recipes the Chesapeake Bay has to offer too.
My granddad was a Navy man and retired in Harford County, near the Susquehanna River. Many a summer were spent catching and then steaming blue crabs (coated in unholy amounts Old Bay seasoning, of course).
I think I could pick a blue crab clean before I could ride a bike. Granddad had an old house boat and would load up me and my cousins (all boys) to go out on the Chesapeake for long weekends.
We'd stop by the PX to load up on flats of Shasta soda, cartons of eggs, loaves of bread and raw chicken legs then head out. We'd tie the chicken legs all around the boat and pull crabs in all day, which we'd eat for every meal.
We'd spread newspaper over the table and eat hot, steamed crabs dipped in butter for supper then pick and save any extra crab meat.
Grandad would make some sort of creamed sauce (probably a hollandaise of sorts) with crab which he'd ladle over eggs and toast for breakfast. We'd make a "lobster roll" type sandwich with warm buttered bread and crab for lunch then start all over again that night with more hot, steamed crabs.
My cousins became phenomenal swimmers and divers and grew up to compete on their high school teams. One even went to college on a diving scholarship and I know it was because of the hours and HOURS we spent jumping off Grandad's boat and swimming in the Bay.
Between the putrid chicken parts we handled in the hot sun, diving from the high roof of the boat and swimming without lifejackets (or much supervision), I'm surprised we all survived. Surely one of us should have contracted salmonella poisoning, drowned or at least broken an arm.
But nope, we all made it out alive. Year after year.
As with every regional recipe, there are strong opinions about the "right way" to make them. Grandma didn't always put celery and onion in hers but when she did, she diced them very fine and I always liked them best this way.
I have never, ever seen anyone from Maryland put bell peppers in their crab cakes but if you like them that way, by all means, dice some and add them to the recipe!
The only thing EVERYONE agrees on is that you MUST season the crab cakes with Old Bay Seasoning. Old Bay is easy to come by throughout the east coast and southeast but if you're somewhere you can't find it, this combination should get you through!
Recipe for How to Cook Maryland-Style Crab Cakes
Grandma's Maryland-Style Crab Cakes
Ingredients
- 1 pound blue crab meat
- 1/2 cup finely diced celery (optional)
- 1/2 cup finely diced onion (optional)
- 1 teaspoon yellow mustard
- 1 1/2 tablespoons mayonnaise
- 1 egg, beaten
- 1 tablespoon parsley
- 1/2 teaspoon paprika
- 1 tablespoon Old Bay seasoning
- 2 slices bread, cut into small cubes
- 2 tablespoons butter
- 1 tablespoon celery salt
- 2 tablespoons paprika
- 1 teaspoon mustard powder
- 1 teaspoon black pepper
- 1/2 teaspoon ground white pepper
- 1/4 teaspoon cayenne pepper
- 1/8 teaspoon ground cloves
- 1/8 teaspoon ground nutmeg
Instructions
- If baking, preheat oven to 375 degrees.
- Add mustard, mayonnaise, egg, parsley, paprika and Old Bay seasoning to a medium bowl then mix until thoroughly combined.
- Add crab meat, celery, onion and bread cubes to bowl then gently stir with a rubber spatula or wooden spoon until just combined.
- Melt butter then brush the cups of a muffin tin with butter.
- Divide crab mixture evenly into cups of muffin tin. Press the mixture down to compress it a little (this helps them keep their shape when done). Bake at 375 degrees for 30 minutes or until golden brown.
- Let crab cakes rest 5 minutes in the muffin tin. Slide a knife around the edges of each crab cake to loosen then remove.
- Squeeze crab cakes with fresh lemon juice when serving if desired.
- Coat the bottom of a large skillet with vegetable oil then add 2 tablespoons butter. Heat over medium heat until butter starts to foam.
- Portion out 12 crab cakes, using your hands to gently shape and compress them a little.
- Fry crab cakes 3-4 minutes on each side (or until browned and they flip without sticking).
- Squeeze crab cakes with fresh lemon juice when serving if desired.
Notes
- Old Bay Seasoning is easy to come by throughout the east coast and southeast but if you're somewhere you can't find it, combine the ingredients listed above.
- As with every regional recipe, there are strong opinions about the "right way" to make these. The celery and onions are optional. Grandma didn't always add them but when she did, she diced them very fine and I always liked them best this way.
- I have never, ever seen anyone from Maryland put bell peppers in their crab cakes but if you like them that way, by all means, dice some and add them to the recipe!
Can you just bake these on a cookie sheet?
ReplyDeleteI don't think they'd keep their shape. But if you decide to try it, I'd love to know how it turns out!
DeleteWonder if you could cook these in a pannini (sp) press
DeleteThese will bake fine. If they are firm enough to fry, they are firm enough to bake. If you cook them in a panini press, they will fall apart. I'm from Baltimore and we use saltines instead of bread and a hefty couple of dashes of worcestershire sauce.
DeleteNot sure where the comment button is so I'll just add a comment.... I just made these and have to say the taste is out of this world! They did not hold up though once I took them out of the muffin tins. So disappointing. Glad I made this just for my husband and not his folks...
DeleteI bake my Maryland Style carb cakes on a cookie sheet and they stay together very well. I also ommit the bread. Up the wet ingredients just slightly. The bread is mostly a binder.
DeleteThanks for the great share! Pinning and plan on making your family recipe as soon as I get my hands on LUMP Maryland Blue Crab Meat!
ReplyDeleteDang, girl! You've got some pinning power!
ReplyDeleteCrab cakes are my favorite and any time they are on a menu I will order them, just to check them out. And I must say there are many many variations!Can you get Blue crab in Michigan?
ReplyDeleteI really have no idea but I don't *think* so. You can use any crab meat in this recipe. It doesn't have to be blue crab.
DeleteSam's Club carries crabmeat in their seafood section. It's the only place I can get it in Indianapolis that tastes close to the Maryland beautiful swimmers.
DeleteThe seafood truck should be coming up here again soon. I will be checking to see if they carry blue crab... Hope so!
ReplyDeleteI did something similar about a year ago with baking my crab cakes in muffin tins. It works like a charm. Next time I think I'll try your recipe for a little variation.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.kudoskitchenbyrenee.com/2012/08/muffin-tin-baked-crab-cakes.html
Renee - Kudos Kitchen
I made some in mini muffin tins as an appetizer. They were the bomb! Everybody loved them.
DeleteNo celery or onions in true Maryland style crabcakes. Sorry.
ReplyDeleteNot true. I'm from Baltimore and our Moms always looked for a way to stretch the crabmeat. My mom used to use green pepper and celery, but not onions. It's called homestyle. Restaurant style doesn't use any fillers or stretchers. We also use saltines instead of bread and a bunch of worcestershire sauce.
DeleteI agree, born n raised in Balto, we never ever put veggies in the crab cakes. No sauce on them either. Nothing to interfere with the amazing flavor of the blue crab meat.
DeleteI can't sign in other than anonymous or I would. I am Lynn from Maryland. Crabcake pic looks good but believe me, no vegetables in true traditional Maryland crabcakes.
ReplyDeleteWell, all of my Maryland family disagrees with ya on that :o) My grandma never lived a day outside of MD and this is her recipe. Oh, and all you have to do is select 'Name/URL" and type in a name - no URL required.
Deletetrue crab cakes have no veges and I am from Michigan. Everyone.s taste is different so we add what we like to enhance the flavor. I never order them when I am out for dinner as I know I will be disappointed. The ones you make at home are so much better. This sounds like a good recipe, I will try it.
DeleteFrom Maryland here too...No vegetables in a true Md crabcake.Pure crab meat only..it doesn't need anything else! Maybe a saltine or two with some mustard...but that's it :)
DeleteReally! You would spend your time aring this,make these any darn way you like.These were really good.
DeleteWill be trying this thanks
ReplyDeleteI am from Maryland and have lived here all of my life 70 years. This is the kind of crab cake recipe I was raised on. So good to see a traditional Maryland Crab Cake recipe. We are famous for our Maryland Blue Crab Cake recipes.
ReplyDeleteI believe all of you are correct based on where you and your families are located and from. Some areas of Maryland and the Chesapeake Bay have just made crabcakes differently. The Bay is as huge as the world of cooks and recipes. Keep cooking and smiling friends!
ReplyDeleteI've never met a crab cake i liked. Nothing compares to the taste of just plain crab dipped in lemon juice, salt and pepper. I think the "minimalistic" mayonnaise, Worcestershire, olive oil, etc. already distracts too much from the taste and texture of crab.
ReplyDeleteAs a Marylander, I fully admit to being a crab cake snob. I usually scoff at crab cake recipes that claim to be Maryland-style. While I've always used the recipe on the back of the Old Bay container and said I'd never even try another version, I think you may have convinced me. (I'm pretty sure its just because you said you could pick a crab clean before you could ride a bike. That's a sign of a real crab-lover and I can trust you with a crab cake recipe. ) :-)
ReplyDeleteHA! I'm the same way! I never EVER order crab cakes in restaurants because any time I ever have, I've always been disappointed. Thanks for your comment!
DeleteJust discovered your website and I've already found so many fabulous recipes that sound just like home. Want to try the Maryland crab cakes made in the muffin tins (they catch blue crabs here in the florida panhandle but good crab cakes are hard to find). Would love to see more of your mother's recipes that feature crab or that were common to the Chesapeake Bay area. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteim a crab cake addict. living in Illinois is hard to get good crab but I want to try this. I think it will be heavenly
ReplyDeleteMy grandparents lived near Annapolis. I crabbed in the Magothy River. Her crab cakes used Keebler's buttery crackers all crumbly instead of bread. This looks like her recipe. Truly, Maryland crab cakes have no green pepper in them. I always ask the chef at fancy restaurants before I order their version of heaven so as not to be disappointed. I sure miss my grandmother!! Roxanna
ReplyDeleteI'm a "kid" from Canada...no idea what's right or wrong making crabby patties...but so far anything I've made on your blog are stupid awesome... So...like always...going for it...thanks for expanding my horizons AND waste line. ;). You ROCK!!!
ReplyDeleteNever heard of parsley and green pepper in Maryland Crab cakes.
ReplyDeleteAs many times as I have looked at this site, I can't believe I missed this crab cake recipe. I grew up about 20 minutes from the Chesapeake Bay and have personal preference for crab cakes, but this looks like a good one. I don't use any onion as I think it overpowers the delicate crab taste, but to each their own. Also never baked one, but I might try it next time I get home to visit and pick up some good crab meat. The only thing better than a good crab cake is a crab imperial stuffed shrimp made with homemade mayo. Put that under your broiler and give it a try!
ReplyDeleteHi, can these crab cakes be made a day ahead of time and reheated?
ReplyDeleteYes! They're not quite as good but they're still mighty fine!
DeleteDo you use a regular size muffin tin or a mini size tin?
ReplyDeleteYou can use either but if you use the smaller ones reduce the baking time.
DeleteThese sure are full of wonderful flavors! You are so right about mini versions being perfect for holiday entertaining!
ReplyDeleteI grew up in Benedict MD on the Patuxent river. I ate crab all my life. I now live in South Texas and would die for a real Maryland crab cake, any of the above recipes will do. Peacekeeper Deb is correct. Families all over Maryland make crab cakes just a tad bit different from each other. Keep picking, cooking & smiling. I do get very good shrimp here and homemade tortillas.
ReplyDeleteAnnapolis born and raised.... skip the veggies
ReplyDeleteI agree!!
DeleteI've been making my grandmother's crab cakes for over 40 years. She was a tavern cook in Baltimore in the 1940's. Her secret was to refrigerate her crab cakes for at least 2 hours or overnight before broiling. This way they wouldn't fall apart. My favoriat method is deep fried.
ReplyDeleteWould I be able to assemble the night before and then pop in the over the day of?
ReplyDeleteSure!
DeleteI am a Baltimore girl, and we have never put onions, celery or peppers in our crab cakes. We followed the recipe on the Old Bay can, and from the Maryland Seafood cookbook only adding a bit of lemon juice. I guess it’s all about what you are accustomed to. To each his own.❤️
ReplyDelete